Fourth-year students Grogan and
Wells present on their Edinburgh Geriatric Tutorial experience
This story was last edited at 1:35 am March 31,
2005.
by Tara Beverly
Spending your summer in
sometimes cold and rainy Edinburgh, Scotland, may not be a dream
getaway, but making a difference by working with geriatric patients
made a great learning experience for two OU-COM students. And that
was the experience fourth-year students Scott Grogan and
Kimberly Wells had while completing the Charles J. Cannon
Edinburgh Geriatric Tutorial Program last summer. The tutorial is
one of a number of international programs available for students,
which are administered by the college's
Office of
International Programs. While in Scotland,
Grogan and Wells did research, worked with geriatric patients and
managed to plunge themselves into Scottish culture.
Grogan and Wells chose to go to Edinburgh
(pronounced “Ed-in-Bra,” according to Grogan) because of the city's
leading reputation in the field of research geriatrics. In fact, the
health-care system for the elderly is viewed by many as the best in
the Western World. In Grosvenor Hall February 18, Grogan and Wells
did a PowerPoint presentation on their Edinburgh Geriatric Tutorial
experience.
“We wanted to experience and study care of the
elderly in a non-American health-care system. We wanted to see how
others do it,” Wells says. ”They — the Scottish — have a very
different view of geriatrics.”
One thing that they noticed most immediately,
says Wells, is that “the elderly are more revered in Scotland than
in this country. Elderly people even have their own street signs,
which inform drivers that ‘old people are crossing.’”
While in Edinburgh, Grogan and Wells attended
five hours of lecture on some days — complete with traditional
Edinburgh tea breaks and lunch. On other days they trained with
geriatric physicians that treated the elderly in nursing homes,
hospitals and home hospices, during which the pair were able to
study various aspects of geriatric clinical care.
In addition to attending lectures and doing
clinical rotations, Grogan and Wells had to complete research papers
on the health-care system they were being trained in.
“In their health-care system, physicians have
much more decision-making power over treatment, especially the
treatment of terminally ill patients,” says Wells.
“There is a national health system, the National
Health Service, that the government supports. Private hospitals
exist as well, but they are paid for out-of-pocket by patients or
through private insurance.”
Also, they note, that it is not as crucial for
the elderly to plan for the end of life as it is in America; the
health-care system there seems to accommodate better for their
treatment at the end of life. Also there are laws help to maintain
the autonomy of the elderly as they near the end of life.
Grogan and Wells found that there are pluses and
minuses to having a national health-care system. Higher taxes are a
“negative,” for instance. Some physicians also may be paid less than
ones performing similar work in the United States. But there are
generally shorter working hours, and the environment is much more
relaxed.
Patient discharge planning can be more difficult
because of the complexity of resolving outpatient treatment and
living arrangement issues, which may result in longer hospital
stays.
Even with lectures, clinical rotations and
research, Grogan and Wells found that their “workdays” were
generally finished by the middle-to-late afternoon.
“We had a very flexible work schedule, which left
us with plenty of time to explore,” says Grogan.
“We visited Holyrood Park, which is located in
the center of the city, kind of like New York’s Central Park,”
Grogan says. “I also got to play golf, one of my favorite sports.”
“The Highlands and the Doune Castle (Monty
Python’s “Holy Grail” Castle) were cool to see,” adds Wells. “Going
to pubs and joining the locals in ceilidh, which involves
traditional Scottish dancing, was very enjoyable,” Wells says.
The two students lived in an international dorm
while in Edinburgh.
“It was interesting living in the international
dorm. We met a lot of nice people from different countries,” says
Grogan.
“He met his Scottish girlfriend there,” Wells
jokingly adds.
“Although we had single rooms, we had a communal
kitchen that everyone used. It was very expensive to eat out, so we
tried to cook a lot at home,” says Grogan.
“If you go out to eat in Scotland, you have to
try haggis,” they say.
“It’s much better than people have been led to
believe,” says Grogan. “I recommend it highly!”
“It was a wonderful eye-opening experience to
live in such a different culture,” says Wells. All in all the two
say they had a great time.
“I plan to go back in April,” says Grogan.
Maybe to visit that girlfriend.